Reconciling applicant-reported roof material against imagery

The ACORD roof material field is one line on a form. The applicant, or more often whoever filled out the form for them, picks from a short list: asphalt shingle, tile, metal, wood shake, built-up, membrane. Nobody checks a box labeled "not sure" even when they are not sure. The field gets filled in because the form requires it, not because anyone climbed on the roof.
That's the gap underwriters run into every renewal season. A roof reported as architectural shingle on the application might be three-tab instead. A roof marked "tile" might be asphalt with a tile-look ridge cap. None of this is fraud, usually. It's just that roof material is a visual fact and the form is a text field, and those two things drift apart the longer a policy sits on the books without a reinspection.
Why the self-reported field doesn't hold up on its own
The roof material entry on an application is filled out once, often at binding, and then it sits there unchanged through renewal after renewal unless something forces a second look. A claim. A reinspection triggered by catastrophe modeling. A random audit. Outside of those triggers, the field is whatever was typed in year one, carried forward.
That would be fine if roof material never changed and applicants never guessed. Neither is true. Owners replace a damaged section with whatever material is on hand or whatever the roofer recommends, and the ACORD field doesn't get updated. A prior owner's disclosure gets copied onto a new owner's application. Someone fills out the form from memory, or from what the listing agent wrote, and tile becomes shingle or shingle becomes tile.
The form says what someone typed in. The open question is how long ago anyone last looked at the roof itself.
A reconciliation workflow that doesn't require a site visit
Reconciling the two doesn't have to mean sending an inspector to every address before bind. It means pulling an independent read of the roof and setting it next to the form.
At GSD of 0.3 m or better, VHR imagery, whether satellite or aerial, resolves roof covering at the level of detail underwriting needs: shingle versus tile versus metal versus membrane, along with roof geometry (gable, hip, flat) and storey count. Captured annually and delivered as a structured record per address, that gives underwriting something to check the application field against before the policy binds, not after a claim forces the question.
The workflow is simple once the record exists:
- Pull the imagery-derived roof material for the address.
- Compare it to the ACORD field on the application.
- If they match, move on. Nothing to flag.
- If they don't, the underwriter decides whether the mismatch changes the rate, triggers a question to the agent, or just gets noted in the file.
That last step still belongs to a person. The imagery tells you what's on the roof. It doesn't tell you why the form says something else, and it shouldn't be asked to.
What imagery settles, and what it doesn't
RGB imagery at this resolution is good at the visual distinctions that matter for roof material classification: the texture and pattern differences between asphalt shingle, tile, metal panel, and membrane are visible from directly overhead. It won't tell you the age of the roofing, the underlayment, or whether a metal roof is standing-seam versus screw-down at a level of confidence you'd want to price off alone. Treat it as the independent read that either confirms the form or tells you to ask another question, not as a replacement for every other piece of the file.
Annual cadence matters here too. A roof material mismatch caught at the next renewal cycle is a pricing conversation. One caught after a wind claim is a coverage dispute. Reconciling the field against imagery before bind, and again at renewal, moves that conversation to the cheaper side of the calendar.
If you want to see what that per-address record looks like for a book you're about to bind, Property Characteristics builds it from the imagery before the question ever becomes a claim.
Start with one address on your renewal list and see what the imagery shows against the form.